PRICING STRUCTURES
Most merchants don't realize how their processor pricing actually works — which is why they overpay. Here's the plain-English breakdown of every structure you might be on, when each is the right call, and what to watch for.
WHY THIS MATTERS
Processor pricing is one of those topics that's been deliberately made confusing. Not because it's actually complex — the math is high-school arithmetic — but because confusion is profitable. The longer you don't understand your statement, the longer you keep paying whatever your processor decides to charge.
Every business should know which structure they're on, why, and whether it's the right one for their card mix and ticket size. This page covers all four. By the end, you'll be able to read your own statement and tell whether you're on the right pricing — or quietly bleeding money you shouldn't be.
Bundles transactions into "qualified," "mid-qualified," and "non-qualified" buckets. Convenient on paper. Bleeds money in practice.
HOW IT WORKS
Your processor groups every transaction into one of three tiers. "Qualified" gets the lowest rate (the one you saw on the sales sheet). "Mid-qualified" and "non-qualified" get progressively higher rates. The rules for which tier a transaction lands in are written by the processor — not by Visa or Mastercard — and they're rarely transparent.
WHY IT'S USUALLY WRONG
Most merchants are sold on the "qualified" rate, but the majority of their transactions actually fall into the higher tiers. Rewards cards, business cards, corporate cards, and any card-not-present transaction often "downgrade" to non-qualified — and the merchant doesn't see this happening unless they read the statement carefully.
WHEN TIERED PRICING MIGHT STILL MAKE SENSE
Almost never. Specifically, only if you process exclusively low-risk debit cards in a face-to-face environment and your processor offers a flat tier-1 rate with no downgrade penalties. That's rare.
WHAT TO WATCH FOR IN YOUR STATEMENT
One number for every transaction. Easy to understand. Easy to overpay if you're at scale.
HOW IT WORKS
Your processor charges the same rate on every transaction regardless of card type. Stripe (2.9% + 30¢), Square (2.6% + 10¢), PayPal (3.49% + 49¢) — these are flat-rate processors. No tiers, no downgrades, no surprises.
WHY IT'S A REAL OPTION FOR SOME MERCHANTS
Flat-rate is the right call for low-volume merchants (under $15k/mo in cards) and for very-low-touch merchants who don't want to think about processing at all. The simplicity has a cost — you're paying a premium over what interchange-plus would charge — but for the right business, the simplicity is worth it.
WHY IT'S USUALLY WRONG FOR ESTABLISHED BUSINESSES
Once your monthly card volume crosses ~$15k, flat-rate pricing starts costing you significant money. The processor is charging you the same rate on a $5 debit card as on a $500 corporate rewards card — and the cost difference between those two transactions to the processor is enormous. They keep the difference.
WHEN FLAT-RATE IS THE RIGHT CALL
WHAT TO WATCH FOR IN YOUR STATEMENT
You see the wholesale cost (interchange) plus the processor's markup. Most transparent option for established businesses.
HOW IT WORKS
Every card transaction has a true wholesale cost called interchange — set by Visa and Mastercard, not your processor. Interchange varies by card type (debit is cheaper, rewards is more expensive, corporate is the most expensive). On interchange-plus pricing, your processor charges you exactly the interchange rate plus a fixed markup (e.g., interchange + 0.50%).
WHY THIS IS THE BEST FIT FOR MOST ESTABLISHED BUSINESSES
Total transparency. You can see what each transaction actually costs. You're not subsidizing high-cost cards by paying the same rate on debit. The processor's profit margin is fixed — they make the same percentage whether your customer pays with a debit card or an Amex Platinum. No incentive to upcharge.
WHY MERCHANTS DON'T ALREADY KNOW ABOUT IT
Two reasons. (1) Most processor sales reps don't lead with interchange-plus because the upfront rate looks "higher" than tiered or flat-rate (e.g., "interchange + 0.50%" sounds worse than "1.79% qualified" until you do the math). (2) The statements are slightly more complex to read at first — you see interchange and markup as separate line items.
WHEN INTERCHANGE-PLUS IS THE RIGHT CALL
WHAT TO WATCH FOR IN YOUR STATEMENT
Cash and card prices side by side. Card customers pay a small fee. Best for tight-margin businesses.
HOW IT WORKS
You display two prices: the "cash price" (what cash and check customers pay) and the "card price" (slightly higher to cover processing fees). Customers paying by card pay the card price, which means most of your processing cost is offset by the customer rather than absorbed into your margin.
WHY THIS IS POWERFUL
For tight-margin businesses (restaurants, food trucks, salons, contractors), processing fees can eat 1–3% of total revenue. Dual pricing or cash discount can recover most of that — meaning the savings drop straight to the bottom line.
WHY THIS REQUIRES CARE
Dual pricing has compliance rules: Visa and Mastercard have specific requirements about how the two prices must be displayed, what signage must be posted, and how the surcharge is calculated. Some states (e.g., Colorado, Connecticut, Maine, Massachusetts, Oklahoma, and a handful of others) restrict surcharging entirely or have specific disclosure requirements. Done wrong, you can get warning letters or account holds.
WHEN DUAL PRICING / CASH DISCOUNT IS THE RIGHT CALL
WHAT TO WATCH FOR IN YOUR STATEMENT (AFTER IMPLEMENTATION)
WHICH ONE IS RIGHT FOR YOU?
The right structure depends on your card mix, your average ticket size, your monthly volume, your customer demographics, your tolerance for customer-facing pricing changes, and your tolerance for compliance complexity. There's no shortcut answer that fits every business — and any rep who tells you there is, is selling you a structure they get paid to sell.
The free 24-hour analysis I offer reads your actual statement, looks at your actual card mix and volume, and tells you which structure (or combination) actually fits your business. About 30% of merchants who run the analysis end up keeping their current structure (with renegotiated pricing). The other 70% switch — usually to interchange-plus, sometimes to dual pricing, occasionally to a hybrid.
FIND OUT WHICH ONE FITS YOU
The fastest way to know which structure fits your business is to send me your last statement. 24 hours later you'll have a real answer — backed by your actual numbers.
RECOMMENDED
60 seconds to submit. 24 hours later you'll have a personalized analysis showing your effective rate, where the leaks are, and which structure fits.
Send the statementPREFER TO TALK FIRST
Quick conversation about your current setup. Ask anything about pricing structures, dual pricing compliance, or contract language.
Pick a timeReplies within one business day · No automated follow-ups · You won't be added to any list